Bobby Vee
Bobby
Vee got his first experience as a Buddy substitute when pressed into service
as his replacement in the Winter Dance
Party
tour. During the early sixties, he released many BH-esque tunes and covers,
including the albums "Bobby Vee Meets the
Crickets"
and "I Remember Buddy Holly". One highlight of the Crickets/Bobby Vee collaboration,
IMHO, is the emotionally
arrested
(and ironically titled) "He's Old Enough to Know Better" ("If he shows
at her place, I'm gonna hit him in the face").
Bobby
Vee is a little *too* much like Buddy. In his attempt to imitate the Great
Myopic One down to the last detail, he
ultimately
loses...because, sadly, there can be only one Buddy. However, the zenith
in Holly-style recording is without a doubt
his
"Rubber Ball," which in 1961 reached #6 on the American charts. I love
this song, but the concept of a guy comparing
himself
to elastomeric objects hurts my head if I think about it for too long.
Adam Faith
Aided
by John Barry's (of James Bond theme fame) excellent string arrangements,
Adam Faith inhabited the British pop charts
quite
frequently from 1959-1962. His first #1 hit, "What Do You Want" (done in
the U.S. by Bobby Vee in 1960), is a classic
exercise
in Holly stuttering. Many of his other hits have a similar cast, including
"Someone Else's Baby," "How About That?,"
"The
Time Has Come," and the neurosis-ridden "Who Am I?"
Mike Berry
The
British Buddy Holly. Mike Berry could look like Arnold Schwartzenegger
in person for all I know, but on tape he sounds
just
like Our Hero. In fact, the Crickets enlisted Berry as their lead singer
for a 1963 U. K. tour. His "My Baby Doll" is the best
Buddy
knockoff track ever recorded, in my opinion. "Set Me Free" is a close second:
Hank Williams lyrics; Buddy Holly
vocals.
Wow! "What's The Matter" and the mildly suggestive "Don't You Think It's
Time" (true Holly overdubbing, true Joe
Meek
low-fi engineering) are also clearly Buddy-inspired. Berry also recorded
"Tribute to Buddy Holly," which hit #24 in the
British
charts in 1961.
Joe Meek
Say
what you will about maverick British record producer Joe Meek: He was,
by the standards of the day, a sexual pervert. He
was
tone-deaf. He was a space alien fanatic. He blew away his landlady with
a twelve-gauge shotgun. But damn it, he loved
Buddy
Holly.
Meek,
a most truly unique individual, was the genius behind Mike Berry. His legendary
obsession with the Great Myopic One
prompted
him (in addition to a number of more bizarre acts of devotion, such as
regular seances to seek Buddy's advice on
recordings)
to cobble Berry into his own personal Holly impersonator. How'd you think
Mike got the name of BERRY,
anyway?
Meek's
obsession is apparent as well in the Dead Boyfriend (and Girlfriend) theme
which sums up, oh, about ninety per cent of
his
releases. Pamela Blue's "My Friend Bobby," which Meek produced, is a classic
example (about ten seconds into this song,
it's
obvious that we're supposed to sing "my friend Buddy" instead). He also
produced the Honeycombs' most excellent "Have I
The
Right," which hit #5 in the states in 1964. Although not a Holly Impersonator
tune in the least, somehow the lyrics to this
little
gem (not to mention the gratuitous stair-stomping) just fit right in.
The Crickets
After
Buddy's death, the Crickets continued to play and record in spite of what
Alan V. Karr described as a "revolving door" of
personnel
changes. It is natural that their later releases would be sort of Buddy-esque,
especially since they continued to write
and
record with producer Norman Petty. Through the revolving door passed some
pretty good lead singers, such as David
Box,
Earl Sinks and Jerry Naylor.
Earl
Sinks fronted the Crickets on "I Fought the Law," "A Sweet Love," and an
excellent remake of "Love's Made a Fool of
You."
His "Someone, Someone" (written by Vi Petty), is quite moving. My all-time
favorite Earl Sinks song, however, is "When
You
Ask About Love," which has always struck me as the appearance of Buddy's
asshole alterego.
Jerry
Naylor's vocals come a little closer to Buddy imitation, especially on
"My Little Girl," which has Jerry Allison reprising the
drum
solo from "Peggy Sue" and some of the goofiest lyrics I've ever heard (his
little girl must be pretty damned incredible, if
when
she goes to the movies, nobody looks at the screen). "Teardrops Fall Like
Rain" is a very good track in the true Love
Victim
Buddy tradition.
Random Stuff
Although I know little about their respective careers, here are some other singers who in at least one tune do the Buddy Thing:
The
Searchers: Don't Cha Know. Wonder if they took their name from that
John Wayne movie where he says, "That'll be the
day"?
Ricky Wayne and the Offbeats: Goodness Knows. Uh-oh, nice guitar reverb!
Lee Diamond and the Cherokees : I'll Step Down. Serious Voice Thing, but a very un-Buddy like lack of determination.
Billy Fury: Halfway to Paradise. True cheese, but still...
Tommy
Roe: Sheila. A classic Buddy knockoff (#1 in the Billboard charts in
'62), but come on. Her name drives him insane?
Would
someone please get Tommy some Ritalin?
Shane Fenton and the Fentones: Walk Away. What hiccupping...*sigh*
Cliff Richard and the Shadows: Please Don't Tease
Steve
Marriott: Give Her My Regards. Steve's got a true Voice Thing going
here, and the harpsichord recalls the celeste line
from
"Everyday." Four stars.
The
Nighthawks: When Sin Stops Love Begins. Eddie Reeves should have no
problem getting either love or sin, with his voice.
Buddy
himself plays the guitar solo. Double *sigh*
The
Five Chesternuts: Teenage Love. I'm compelled to offer this insipid tune
by virtue of its vocal style. Somehow, though, I
can't
imagine ole Buddy singing the line, "a boy and a girl and a seat for two,
a paradise with nothing else to do" with a straight
face.
Recent Buddy Impersonators
While
most of the gratuitous Buddy wannabes flourished before 1966, the Great
Myopic One's vocal style still pops up
occasionally
in the form of influence or tribute. While some would disagree, I would
name Dave Edmunds as a minor BH
impersonator
("The Watch On My Wrist" is a good example). Young Texans should recall
The Judys' David Bean uh-uh-ing his
way
through "She's Got The Beat" and the very un-Buddylike "Guyana Punch."
No one would ever mistake C&W pretty-boy
Dwight
Yoakam for Our Hero, but "Near You" from his CD Gone is a great Buddy-esque
song (listen closely to the title track
as
well). And let's not even talk about Marshall Crenshaw.
Blasphemy
This
has little relevance to the subject of Buddy Impersonators, but somehow
Nirvana's "Lithium" seems vaguely Buddy-like to
me
(to-DAY, ah-FOUND, m'-FRIEND...) Similarly, I think that the Ramones' "Sheena
Is A Punk Rocker" is the ideological
grandchild
of "Peggy Sue." Go ahead, flame me.